Old Normal
Masks show obedience
Masks don't stop viruses

Masks

masks work

The Bottom Line

A retrospective study on the use of face masks to control Covid since 2020 highlights the things we've learned over decades and the mistakes of current politicians. This study provides many graphs showing globally just how ineffective mask mandates have been in reducing the spread of infection and explains why. Simply, it finds that mask mandates have not shown a shred of real-world evidence of efficacy. The old normal way of behaviour is as safe as any other.

A Gathering of evidence

This gathering is from early 2022. There are more references below to earlier findings.

PANDA is a group of multi-disciplinary professionals. As a politically and economically independent organisation, PANDA seeks to develop science-based explanations and test them against international data. PANDA stands for open science and rational debate and retrieving liberty and prosperity from the clutches of a dystopian future. Here's a link to their mask studies.

HART is a group of highly qualified UK doctors, scientists, economists, psychologists and other academic experts. They came together over shared concerns about policy and guidance recommendations relating to the COVID-19 pandemic. They continue to be concerned about the lack of open scientific debate in mainstream media and the worrying trend of censorship and harassment of those who question the narrative. As for UK schools, it would seem that Nadhim Zahawi's promised 'material' evidence for his recommendations for face coverings in secondary classrooms is as flimsy as some of the cloth masks our teenagers will need to resort to using. — findings from HART.

The Brownstone Institute for Social and Economic Research is a nonprofit organization founded May 2021. They publish a wide variety of perspectives and viewpoints, including contradictory views by different authors. Here's their summary of about 150 mask studies.

The notional face covering

Since the mandating of face coverings in July 2020 people have created or purchased all sorts of wonderful things and almost none of these comply with even the lowest standards for control of airborne disease. However, they comply with the law even if they're completely useless. Bear this in mind as you read on.

Building friendships by smiling is endangered

If you wear a mask you cannot communicate as a normal human — you are faceless. In a social setting facial expression is vital to communication. Think about it... On a street, in a shop, on a bus, on a train, in fact almost everywhere - no smiles - no engagement - no warmth - no new friends. In "old normal" times people knew that anyone wearing a mask was wearing a disguise.

Face masks — instructed belief

why bother with your maskDespite masks being mandated, the rise in cases has not stopped. Many people wear them out of fear of being harassed or punished. As this epidemic evolves, the wearing of face masks cannot be seen as one of the major factors of success and thus validated. There are reports that face masks might have some effect but these generally admit an obligation to say that, despite evidence to the contrary. (see Studies found on the Internet).

(Interestingly, in researching this we found that Google, YouTube, Facebook and previously respectable publications actually censor information if it questions official doctrine.)

A face mask cult

After 2 years of living with people who continue to choose to wear face masks we know they have become believers. This article links to a comprehensively researched book on the subject. It lays out the case for masks in detail, considers the harms done by mask-wearing (harms which are usually ignored by scientists and governments), closely examines many claims made about masks by both sides, and backs it all up with an enormous number of references to the scientific literature.

Political influence

If you thought politics doesn't influence information just take a look at this: an article no longer available. Published in 2016, long before Covid-19 struck and not intended to counter the current policy, however, it's now deemed to be inappropriate and has been removed.
redacted article about masks in dentistry
However, you can decide for yourself whether the article is informative or not by reading the original here. Any rational person would have thought it highly relevant to today's problems. An article written in 2016, long before politicians got involved. This article is about dentistry and, of course, very close contact.

...Between 2004 and 2016 at least a dozen research or review articles have been published on the inadequacies of face masks. All agree that the poor facial fit and limited filtration characteristics of face masks make them unable to prevent the wearer inhaling airborne particles. In their well-referenced 2011 article on respiratory protection for healthcare workers, Drs. Harriman and Brosseau conclude that, "facemasks will not protect against the inhalation of aerosols." Following their 2015 literature review, Dr. Zhou and colleagues stated, "There is a lack of substantiated evidence to support claims that facemasks protect either patient or surgeon from infectious contamination."...

It concludes:
redacted article about masks in dentistry - conclusion
redacted article about masks in dentistry - conclusion ctd

Video demos showing how masks leak

masks do not stop aerosols
As an example of how aerosols escape from mask and drift around you can watch this video. It's presented by Dr Ted Noel and demonstrates how various masks have negligible effect on passage of aerosols, which are now believed to be the major vector in the transmission of Covid-19. Take heed, others wearing masks are NOT protecting you, even if they believe they are.

masks definitely do not stop aerosols To be fair, there are a lot of articles on YouTube and the Internet that insist masks are effective — many these are based on anecdote and reference to other diseases and the more honest articles suggest that masks MIGHT help, but "might" is not good enough, especially if you're relying on it. The video on the right is from a guy who is definitely pro-mask, but even his demo falters when his "best" mask needs a second attempt. If you're relying on "MIGHT help" you're a long way from proof or a guarantee.

The possibility that masks "might" help needs to be weighed against possibility of the opposite. And then weighed against the psychological effect of having half your face removed when you should be engaging with other people with smiles and facial expression.

If you have the virus and you think you're protecting others by wearing a mask, bear in mind:

Why would anyone present a case against masks?

The simple truth is that most articles on the Internet are obliged to come down on the side that wearing a mask reduces the spread of coronavirus. However, there are lots of findings that show only a marginal efficacy for masks in other diseases and infer therefore masks work for Covid-19. There is a ton of evidence that political pressure affects announcements from august institutions like the WHO, the CDC and the British Government, and that true science has no part to play in this. Here's a Canadian article on the subject explaining just how mask mandates are excused.

In many countries mandating the wearing of masks in public coincided with a significant rise in infections. Although this mandate cannot be proven to have caused the rise, and such a notion is firmly dismissed officially, nonetheless, the mandate did not not cause a reduction in infections — which was presumably the intention, so had no proven benefit but a suspicion of dis-allowed consequences.

All the studies published early in this pandemic "proving" masks were effective came with a caveat that keeping a distance from other people should be used in conjunction; which is to say that keeping a safe distance is essential if the mask is to work. A nice bit of psychology - if you wear a mask and don't go near anyone the mask is saving you, so wear a mask. Worth a study - (see we need proof).

By August 2020 there was Still No Conclusive Evidence Justifying Mandatory Masks.

And in February 2021 a review of scientific reports of harms caused by face masks found the mounting evidence of the obvious: universal masking harms people and society, without any detectable benefit.

Dehumanising

Whatever else can be said about masks the fact is that wearing them in public is dehumanising. People relate to other people through their faces — their smiles and expressions. Compelling everyone to wear a mask, knowing there is no actual evidence of efficacy and that most people will wear them wrongly, is against our human rights.

Coronaphobia

Keeping a sensible distance from people is probably more effective than wearing a mask (see Studies found on the Internet, below). Generally it's acknowledged that close proximity needs to be for minutes rather than seconds, so briefly passing close to someone in a shop is unlikely to be a risk. Similarly walking with someone or passing someone outdoors is a negligible risk. Elevating a negligible risk to irrational behaviour indicates a phobia.

In this case wearing a mask is a demonstration of fear.

Showing solidarity

World Health Organisation reverses course
On 4th April: "'There may be situations where the wearing of masks may reduce the rate at which infected individuals may infect others,' Ryan said."
A reversal of course based on what? "may" leaves open the possibility of "may not". Hardly conclusive. And how long had the situation with Covid been researched, as by 4th April 2020 Covid had only been with us a few weeks.

Cambridge Research on face coverings suggests
On 27th July: "While it is not clear how much of an effect face coverings have, scientists have urged policymakers to encourage the wearing of face coverings because the risks are minimal while the potential impact is important in the context of the COVID-19 pandemic."
Note that political pressure is being applied.

World Health Organisation says masks are a sign of solidarity
On 3rd August: "This week, we’re also launching a mask challenge with partners from around the world and we’re encouraging people to send in photos of themselves wearing a mask. As well as being one of the key tools to stop the virus, the mask has come to represent solidarity."
That a mask is key tool is unproven. Encouraging the wearing of masks to show solidarity is political - like waving a flag - proving your allegiance.

In this case a mask represents a belief that they're part of a larger body.

Showing you care

For some people it's not a matter of fear or solidarity, it's showing that they care about the possibility of transmitting the virus, even when they know they have no chance of having it.

In this case a mask represents their virtue.

Going with the flow

The government still encourages wearing "face coverings" in most public places - a whole list of places and dependent on whether you're standing up or sitting down! [ Who makes up this stuff? ]

In this case wearing a mask indicates you're concerned that someone will challenge you. You don't want to argue. You have no opinion in the matter. This what most people all over the world have felt when invaded by a new power — just get on with it and keep your head down. Never mind the atrocities being committed to others - I'm safe for the time being.

This is probably the majority.

Studies found on the Internet

A pro-mask news feature published 6th October 2020: Face masks: what the data say

"For now, Osterholm, in Minnesota, wears a mask. Yet he laments the 'lack of scientific rigour' that has so far been brought to the topic. 'We criticize people all the time in the science world for making statements without any data,' he says. 'We're doing a lot of the same thing here.'

Nevertheless, most scientists are confident that they can say something prescriptive about wearing masks. It's not the only solution, says Gandhi, 'but I think it is a profoundly important pillar of pandemic control'. As Digard puts it: 'Masks work, but they are not infallible. And, therefore, keep your distance.'"

An update on 25 October 2020 found at Swiss Policy Research concludes: Cloth face masks in the general population might be effective, at least in some circumstances, but there is currently little to no evidence supporting this proposition. If the SARS-2 virus is indeed transmitted via indoor aerosols, cloth masks are unlikely to be protective. Health authorities should therefore not assume or suggest that cloth face masks will reduce the rate or risk of infection.

However, in the body of the report it lists many studies that found masks to be ineffective and many studies that claimed masks were effective but these studies were flawed.

Within the article it notes The WHO admitted to the BBC that its June 2020 mask policy update was due not to new evidence but "political lobbying": "We had been told by various sources WHO committee reviewing the evidence had not backed masks but they recommended them due to political lobbying. This point was put to WHO who did not deny." (D. Cohen, BBC Medical Correspondent).

Worth reading in full...

The triangle below nicely shows that valuable and verifiable studies are few and valuable whilst expert opinions are many. It's easy to find an "expert" to support a policy. Maximum strength of evidence is at the top with minimum degree of bias. Not for nothing is the Randomised Controlled Trial considered the "gold standard" of clinical practice. (Graphic by Masha Krylova/ C2C Journal) Part 1 of a valuable critique. Unfortunately RCTs must abide by the rules of "expert opinion", otherwise they don't get published.

power triangle

Censorship - truth removed

Importantly, some Internet articles on the study of efficacy of masks have been removed or retracted because they do not follow official guidance. Whilst this does not prove an attempt to limit freedom of information it does raise questions about censorship.

Take for instance this link to the Center for Infectious Diseases at the University of Minnesota. If it still works you can see in there:

Editor's Note: The authors added the following statement on Jul 16 [2020].
The authors and CIDRAP have received requests in recent weeks to remove this article from the CIDRAP website. Reasons have included:
(1) we don’t truly know that cloth masks (face coverings) are not effective, since the data are so limited,
(2) wearing a cloth mask or face covering is better than doing nothing,
(3) the article is being used by individuals and groups to support non-mask wearing where mandated and
(4) there are now many modeling studies suggesting that cloth masks or face coverings could be effective at flattening the curve and preventing many cases of infection.


Where are the modeling studies referred to in (4), and the word "could" is hardly convincing. This is political pressure and not science.

Here's another interesting take on it at do face masks work - 8 peer reviewed studies.
masks research

And this one the plain truth about masks

Do benefits outweigh the harms?

Whilst masks are a successful psychological tool to remind the public to remain alert, they are not effective in preventing the community spread of disease.

Some more interesting studies on masks here:
Masks Are Neither Effective Nor Safe: A Summary Of The Science

Masks, false safety and real dangers, Part 1: Friable mask particulate and lung vulnerability

Even the BBC can report that politicians over-rule medics.

Another post highlighting the dubious benefit of masks and the politics involved.

And here's the British Medical Journal (BMJ) telling how the government is "following the science".

The Bottom Line (again)

A retrospective study on the use of face masks to control Covid since 2020 highlights the things we've learned over decades and the mistakes of current politicians. This study provides many graphs showing globally just how ineffective mask mandates have been in reducing the spread of infection. It validates everything you could have read above. Simply, it shows that mask mandates have not shown a shred of real-world evidence of efficacy.

A Prepared Mask Policy

If you would like a prepared policy for your organisation or place of work you could use this. It's simply written and contains all the rational explanation you can read above. Feel free to edit it for your own use.


contact
old-normal.org © 2022